Apr 25, · Mandatory national service (also called compulsory service) is a requirement that people serve in the military or complete other works of service. Modern propositions for compulsory service envision that young Americans could join the military or do civilian projects such as teaching in low-income areas, helping care for the elderly, or maintaining infrastructure, among other blogger.comted Reading Time: 9 mins A mandatory military service would mean that a country is prepared for the worst. If, say, a war did break out, it would mean that they would not have to spend as much time recruiting because they would already have trained soldiers there, allowing them to have a head start in the battle side of blogger.comted Reading Time: 4 mins Pros And Cons Of Mandatory Military Service. Words | 4 Pages. Mandatory military service requires every citizen to join and serve in the armed forces, but not every young man or women can handle the intense physical training, furthermore, patriotism will
Should the United States have a period of mandatory service for all citizens? | America Magazine
Currently, the military service in the United States does not presuppose compulsory conscription. Nevertheless, there is still the current practice of recruiting men under the age category from 18 to 25 for the Armed Forces, which raises concerns from a human rights viewpoint.
On the one hand, the recruitment procedure requires especial attention because it is put in effect in case of the threat of war. On the other hand, the military service in the United States is based on volunteering technique. Such a contradiction creates significant problems in terms violation of human rights and most of these procedures are not supported by military and political experts.
Specific attention also requires the U. Selective Service System according to which the registration process excludes the volunteer-based conscription. It also highlights such moral and ethical problems as the right to conscientious objection, recruitment practice initiated by the U. Armed Forces, and limitation to the right to abandon the Military Service.
Therefore, the United States relies on civil citizens to take part in military conflicts. Opinions and outlooks on the conscription and compulsory military services have been changed dramatically over centuries Escott Nevertheless, the historic evidence shows that the mandatory service in the United States has still flashbacks from the past.
The events of the World War II also contributed to the development of the selective service legislation and compulsory recruitment for military service. In this respect, the mandatory conscription was the only defense mechanism for the country to resist aggression during subsequent wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Iraq Johnson 1.
As a result, over 25 years, marked by military actions and the Cold War, the Selective Service System had provided the U.
citizens with new efficient responding mechanisms to react to varied challenges that contradicted the democratic principles. Currently, the debate over the initiative of the Selective Service System to introduce the draft is predetermined by ambivalent vision on the rights and duties of citizens.
On the one hand, the awareness of mandatory national service essay military service is explained by the necessity to ensure protection and security of the American society Johnson 1. Consequently, though the government has integrated selective service during peaceful time, the policy is, first of all, oriented on enriching and broadening the common concept of citizenship, as well as on understanding the democratic aspects of equality, freedom, opportunities, and privileges.
Despite the fact that the military recruitment is recognized as a voluntary action, there is still the legislature that requires men from 18 to 25 to apply for the military service Johnson 1. Inat the threshold of the World War I, the Supreme Court made the decision to introduce mandate military services that excluded the use of the U.
Constitution, particularly the 13 th Amendment revealing human rights to freedom of choice and equality. In this respect, the mandatory national service essay of the draft and its impact on the civilian population until s has created serious problems in terms of the recruitment strategies and obligation to military conscription.
In particular, the case Holmes v. United States reveals that the government is entitled to recruit men in wartime. However, mandatory national service essay, the Court also argued that much concern should be paid to the constitutionality of the conscription due to the absence of the official declaration of war. The debates concerning the number of soldiers needed for ensuring defense system, as well as what expenses these selective service policies will endure provoke further contradictions.
In this respect, Cowen points to the numerous arguments that exclude the possibility of introducing two-fold social organization because the United States should decide whether it should remain a powerful state, or it should maintain the all-volunteer military reform The current gap between civil and military obligations in the country has introduced a number of suggestions to reconsider the necessity for national conscription.
Therefore, the arguments against conscription take advantage over the conservative policy of the draft that lost its actuality since the introduction of neo-liberalist views on social development and democratic welfare.
In fact, Cowen supports the idea that the American liberalism introduces stronger rationale for creating all-voluntary military system than the policies on mandate conscription An in-depth evaluation of the Selective Service reforms in the time of World War II concerning wartime strikes mandatory national service essay significant controversies on the policies in the United States.
In this respect, the legal and ethical basis for developing the draft for other than main purposes is not justified because of the evident violation of civil rights Foster According Blum, wartime strikes have triggered further contradictions mandatory national service essay to the essential purposes of Selective Service Reforms according to which the recruitment for military purposes, but not for the purpose of controlling labor market, should not be approved Though the modern conscription policies admit the conscientious objection to mandate service, there were still inadequate treatment of the U, mandatory national service essay.
As an alternative to the Selective Service System, there is an option of conscientious objection, which implies that individual should be a conscientious objector to all wars, but not to a specific war Blum Apart from the violation of the civil rights of the U.
citizens, the intended conscription has become the controversial issue due to the rise of discriminative policy. In particular, Cowen has stressed that the military services recruited men predominantly from the middle and working classes, which comprised mostly of ethnic minorities and women Therefore, the government has reconsidered the compulsory military recruitment to have found out that labor market dynamic allows to meet ethical and legal concerns regarding individual rights and equality.
Certainly, the mandatory military service creates a number of contradictions concerning the justice and equality of recruiting people, mandatory national service essay. To begin with, the failure to introduce the draft and Selective Service policy seem to be irrational for some reasons.
Specifically, the U. government should focus on the efficient defensive mechanism to maintain the image of a power-state. However, the introduced reforms should be used for other than military services. With regard to the above-presented arguments, it should be stressed the Selective Service System provides contradictory issues concerning the cancellation of conscription in the United States, mandatory national service essay.
In particular, it contradicts the principle of equality and voluntary-based recruitment for military service. Moreover, the conscription terms also violate the constitutional rights of individuals. This is of particular concern to equality, discrimination, and freedom of choice. The U, mandatory national service essay. government, therefore, should reconsider its policy toward middle class population to eliminate the discriminative policy.
The article introduces the main contradictions of the draft and the selective reforms during the Second World War.
The source, therefore, is relevant for the research because it introduces the major debates concerning the adequacy of the Selective Service reforms, mandatory national service essay. In the article, the author provides a wider picture on the conservative approach to treating conscription in the United States, as well as neo-liberalist trends in reshaping the terms of the military service in the United States. Therefore, the article is useful for understanding new solutions toward the reconstructing the military service and social organization.
The book refers to historical background of civil-military relations in mandatory national service essay United States. It provides outlook on conscription at the end of nineteenth century and, therefore, it gives a better understanding of the problems related to current military debates. The article mandatory national service essay an overview of conscientious objection to wartime, as well as contradictions toward Selective Service reform. Such an aspect is useful to consider in the research studies to define how it influences the debate on the mandatory military service.
The case under analysis focuses on the Court decision that undermined the constitutionality of the conscription during the Vietnam War.
Such a perspective introduces a supportive argument against the mandatory military service in the United States. The article under analysis describes the advantages and disadvantages of the Selective Service due to the equality and freedom concerns.
Once again, the source can contribute significantly to the research studies because it explains how conscription constrains violate the civil and moral rights of the U.
Blum, Albert A, mandatory national service essay. Cowen, Deborah. Citizenship Studiesvol. Escott, Paul. Military Necessity: Civil-Military Relations in the Confederacy. Greenwood Publishing Group, mandatory national service essay, Foster, Gregory.
Johnson, mandatory national service essay, Lyndon. Mandatory national service essay 6, Need a custom Proposal sample written from scratch by professional specifically for you?
mandatory national service essay writers online. Mandatory Military Service in the United States. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. If you continue, we will assume that you agree to our Cookies Policy. Introduction Currently, the military service in the United States does not presuppose compulsory conscription. Learn More. We will write a custom Proposal on Mandatory Military Service in the United States specifically for you! Not sure if you can write a paper on Mandatory Military Service in the United States by yourself?
This proposal on Mandatory Military Service in the United States was written and submitted by your fellow student. You are free to use it for research and reference purposes in order to write your own paper; however, you must cite it accordingly, mandatory national service essay.
Removal Request. If you are the copyright owner of this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. Does expeditionary warfare best explain the nature of warfare today? Effective Leadership Traits. GET WRITING HELP. Cite This paper. Select a referencing style:. Copy to Clipboard Copied! APA-6 MLA-8 Chicago N-B Chicago A-D Harvard. Reference IvyPanda. Work Cited "Mandatory Military Service in the United States.
Bibliography IvyPanda. References IvyPanda. More related papers. Check the price of your paper. If you continue, we will assume that you agree to our Cookies Policy OK.
What It's Like To Serve In South Korea's Mandatory Military Service
, time: 4:46Mandatory Military Service in the United States - Words | Proposal Example
Many leverage the 13 th amendment in opposition to mandatory national service, which states, “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted shall exist in the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction” (Pauwels). I agree that our constitution affords us this right, and many other rights; the right to free speech, freedom of Apr 25, · 02/06/ Argument paper. Mandatory National Service Conscription is the mandatory enlistment of individuals in service, usually military or civil. The modern implementation of a national conscription dates back to the French Revolution of Pros And Cons Of Mandatory Military Service. Words | 4 Pages. Mandatory military service requires every citizen to join and serve in the armed forces, but not every young man or women can handle the intense physical training, furthermore, patriotism will
No comments:
Post a Comment